Can You Stain Over Stained Concrete?

I applied a concrete stain to a large 8-year-old concrete patio in Reno, Nevada—an area subject to somewhat extreme temperature variations. I initially washed the patio with a mix of muriatic acid and water to clean it. I hosed it off, waited a day or so, and applied the stain with a sprayer, following the manufacturer's directions. Two years later, the patio now has areas of peeling. I would like to re-stain the whole patio again to make the color more uniform. I have heard that if you have washed a patio with muriatic acid, you cannot acid stain it. I am trying to find an expert who can tell me how to properly prep the surface, apply the stain and protect it. The stain I initially used was an acrylic.

The product you used—a tinted acrylic stain—is not an acid-based concrete stain. It is a translucent concrete paint and is topical, which means it forms a colored coating on the surface of the concrete that will wear over time if not maintained. The surface preparation for these types of stains usually requires acid etching to open the surface to allow the acrylic to adhere to the concrete. But once concrete has been acid etched, the ability of a true acid stain to take is diminished. You will need to do a test to see how the acid stain takes to get a true indication of color and effect.

As far as your particular situation, you should strip off the remaining acrylic stain and clean the surface with soap and water and a clean water rinse. After the area dries, apply the stain, following the directions provided by the stain manufacturer. If you're concerned an acid stain won't take, you may want to reapply the same acrylic stain after cleaning the surface. No matter the stain you use, protecting it with a sealer and proper sealer maintenance will be key to keeping the stain looking good. In your area, plan on resealing every 12 to 16 months.

Find Concrete Stains

Water-Based Concrete Stain Problems

Learn more about how to buy concrete stains.

Return to How to Fix Concrete Acid Stains

Vintage America Acid Stain Organic, antique patina, deep penetrating reactive stain.

Acid Stain by Surfkoat Makes up to 2 gallons. Great for marble look.

Stain-Crete by Increte 9 standard colors. Useful for old or new concrete.

Elements® Transparent Concrete Stain Water-based, environmentally and user-friendly

Concrete Stain + Sealer in One Waterproof, strengthen, preserve and beautify in one step

Stone Tone Stain 10 color options. Resistant to chipping and fading.

Concrete Acid Stain BRICKFORM Blush-Tone Acid Stain available in 10 standard colors

Eco-Friendly, UV-Resistant Stains 15 non-reactive colors that transform concrete.

Semi-Transparent Concrete Stain Eco-Stain by SureCrete, water-based, 30 UV-stable colors.