Pool Deck Throwdown
How Does Concrete Match Up to the Competition?
Homeowners weigh many factors when choosing a material to pave their pool decks, including the cost, slip resistance, upkeep, durability, and how well it complements the surroundings. While concrete certainly isn't the only player in the game, it offers a number of advantages that other pool deck materials can't match, particularly when it comes to versatility. We put concrete to the test in a face-off against some tough competition, including natural stone, pavers, brick and tile. Although all these materials have their pros and cons, we believe concrete is the clear winner in the following categories.
New England Hardscapes Inc in Acton, MA
While pool decks made of flagstone, pavers, or brick have great aesthetic appeal, they can be costly to install because of the labor required to place each unit individually. Many installers find it more economical to pour concrete and apply a pattern than to haul and place paving units by hand. For homeowners on a tight budget, you can still achieve impressive results by mixing stamped concrete with fields of less-expensive plain concrete.
PCM Group Inc in Indianapolis, IN
Ease of Maintenance
All of the paving materials in our face-off are durable and have a long life span, but most of them require more maintenance than concrete. Bricks and paving units can shift over time, requiring releveling or replacement. The joints between paving units also need to be refilled with sand periodically to prevent weed growth. Poured concrete eliminates all these issues, and simply needs occasional cleaning and resealing to maintain its appearance. See this guide to maintaining and caring for exterior decorative concrete.
Patterned Concrete of PA
Compared to darker-colored brick and tile pool decks, which can become extremely hot to the touch after baking in the sun, concrete reflects solar radiation and is more comfortable on bare feet. There are also decorative toppings for concrete that can be used to significantly lower surface temperatures (see What Type of Pool Deck Overlay Will Stay Cool?).
Tom Ralston Concrete in Santa Cruz, CA
Because good traction is especially important on pool deck surfaces, slip resistance is a high priority. All of these pool deck materials can become slippery when wet, especially tile, but with concrete there are several ways to improve the surface traction without detracting from the decorative appearance. These include the use of broomed or exposed aggregate finishes, putting down a textured overlay, or mixing a clear plastic grit into the sealer before it's applied. See Making Concrete Slip Resistant.
Designer Concrete Restoration in Indio, CA
Only decorative concrete gives you the ability to select any shape, size, color and surface treatment for your pool deck—from plain broom-finished concrete, to exposed aggregate, to imprinted patterns that mimic tile, brick or stone. You can also mix and match decorative treatments, such as combining stained concrete with a stenciled or imprinted border or enhancing a colored overlay with sawcut or engraved patterns. To learn more about the design possibilities, see Concrete Pool Deck Surface Ideas.