Jeffrey Girard, P.E.

Home Page

Friday, February 08, 2008

Problems with Inconsistent Color

Question:
I had to repour one piece of a countertop and now the color doesn’t match. What went wrong? And how can I prevent color variations in the future?

Answer:
Color inconsistency between pieces made at different times is not uncommon and is a challenge to prevent. Understanding what influences the final color helps in minimizing or preventing this kind of problem.

Three key factors influencing the final color of concrete are the ingredients in the mix, curing time and environmental conditions. Essentially, the new concrete must be made exactly the same as the original concrete and cured exactly the same under the same conditions.

Inconsistent ingredient control is the prime reason for color variations. Duplicating a given color requires that all of the same ingredients be used and in the exact same proportions. This includes the same sand, the same aggregate, the same brand of pigment, the same superplasticizer and the same amount of water. Variations in water account for most inconsistencies. Water must be weighed out and dosed with the same precision as the other ingredients in the mix. Mixing time and effort also affect the color. More vigorous or longer mixing helps disperse the pigment better than less intense or shorter mixing times.

As for the effects of curing on concrete color, the shorter the curing concrete is kept moist and the sooner it dries out, the less intense the color will be. Prolonged moist curing helps the concrete achieve the desired color. Allowing the concrete to dry prematurely results in a paler, more washed-out tone. Typically concrete should moist cure for at least 7 days before being allowed to dry out, and then it should dry in a slow, controlled fashion.

Lastly, the curing environment (particularly temperature and humidity) can affect concrete color. If it’s much cooler when the new concrete is cast, the lower temperatures slow the curing rate. Warmer temperatures accelerate the curing rate, which can influence color. High humidity slows drying, so the concrete cures longer. Conversely, very low humidity conditions increase the drying rate, leading to washed-out color.